The Repair vs Replace Decision Tree (2026 Edition)
A visual decision framework for knowing exactly when to repair your computer and when it is time to let go.
The 40% Rule
If the repair costs more than 40% of what a comparable new laptop would cost, it is usually better to replace. Below that threshold, repair almost always wins.
Age Is the First Filter
Your laptop's age determines the baseline recommendation before we even look at the specific problem:
0-3 Years Old
REPAIR
Almost always worth it. Modern hardware, parts available, years of life left.
3-6 Years Old
EVALUATE
Depends on the repair cost and your needs. Apply the 40% rule.
6+ Years Old
CONSIDER
Only low-cost repairs make sense. Major repairs rarely justified.
The 7 Most Common Repairs -- Worth It or Not?
Here is our honest breakdown based on thousands of repairs we have done at our Reno repair shop:
The Hidden Cost of Replacing
People underestimate what replacing a laptop actually costs beyond the sticker price: transferring files and settings (2-4 hours), reinstalling software and licenses, relearning a new keyboard layout, and the environmental waste. A repair keeps your familiar setup intact. Our data recovery team can also rescue files from a dying machine if needed.
When Replacement IS the Right Call
We will be honest with you: sometimes repair does not make sense. If your laptop has motherboard damage and is over 5 years old, or if multiple components are failing, the math does not work. In those cases, we can help you sell your broken laptop for cash through our buyback program at SellMyLaptops.com. You will get an instant quote and free shipping.
Not sure which category your laptop falls into? Book a free diagnostic and we will give you the honest numbers. No pressure, no upselling. See our transparent pricing before you come in.
Need professional help?
Book an appointment or call us at (775) 203-1085